Wednesday, July 1, 2009

An Update on Jataka Sara Sangraha

Om Namah Sivaya

Dear Friends,

Here is a small update on “Introduction to Jataka Sara Sangraha”. When I was writing my first article “Jaimini Navamsa” for Saptarishis Astrology On-Line magazine, I culled out the combinations given by Krishna Mishra for devotion towards various sects in Hinduism. I thought it was research work by Krishna Mishra since the combinations are not found in Jaimini Sutras. For example, a combination of Moon and Venus in 12th house from Karaka leads the person to do upasana for worldly purposes. In the present scenario, may it the person works as a priest in temples or if afflicted with a malefic like Rahu or Saturn, and then doing some tantric pujas for others. Let us see one more example. Whenever these malefic combinations like Saturn with Rahu or Ketu with Mars occurs in malefic sign, then the person definitely becomes either a Mantrik or doing such bad kinds of worship. Yet, Krishna Mishra mentions the whenever this combination aspected by Jupiter or occurs in the Jupiter’s sign, then it will be obstructed, that is the person will not involved in such things. Of course, these combinations are yet to be extensively tested.

Now comes the real surprise. When I read the last part of the manuscript of Jataka Sara Sangraha, I found these combinations again got mentioned by Raghava Bhatta exactly matching with Phalaratnamama of Krishna Mishra. Is not a big surprise?

 

Of course, may not be. Raghava Bhatta usually explains the concepts first and then lists out the sutras of Jaimini.. He usually writes thus “तथाच सुत्राणि” (tathāca sutrāṇi) and lists the exact Jaimini sutras pertaining to the concept. He explained all the combinations of for devotion of various deities as in Jaimini Sutras and then listed the 8 sutras starting from

रवि केतुभ्यां शिव भक्तिः

ravi ketubhyāṁ śiva bhaktiḥ. You can have a look at these 8 sutras in this blog “Krishna Mishra Navamsa” and of course we can find them in any Jaimini Sutras commentary.

 

Now, after these all sutras, he explained the other combinations as listed in Phalaratnamala by Krishna Mishra. Again, he gave the exact sutras for these combinations. For example, he writes

तथाच सुत्राणि

tathāca sutrāṇi

शशि गुरुयोगे शुद्ध ब्रह्मज्ञानि

śaśi guruyoge śuddha brahmajñāni

 

शशि शुक्रयोः ऐहिकार्थ देवीमंत्रोपासकः

śaśi śukrayoḥ aihikārtha devīmaṁtropāsakaḥ as they were original Jaimini Sutras. I haven’t found these sutras in any other Jaimini works but the results of these sutras got mentioned in both Phalaratnamala and Jataka Sara Sangraha. Some of these specific combinations, I have used in my Jaimini Navamsa article, which you can find at www.saptarishisastrology.com . Yet the results of the combinations like Moon with Venus, Jupiter with Saturn and Mars etc. are not found in any contemporary Jaimini Sutra commentaries except the ancient ones.

 

Are we missing some sutras in the commentaries available in print? It looks so since these are very specific sutras mentioned by Raghava Bhatta for devotion towards base deities, Lord Hari Hara Suta (May be Lord Ayyappa ?), Vaishnava, Vaidika, Veera Saiva sampradaya etc.

 

Authenticity of Ancient Works:

 

The other day, one serior scholar argued as how far can we believe the authenticity of this Phalaratnasmala, Vriddha Karika etc.? My humble submission to him is the taste of pudding is in eating. He believes in interpreting the Jaimini Sutras with logic. I believe in understanding them with the aid of both grammar and logic. Grammar and Logic are not contradictory to each other but are cooperative and cohesive.

 It was clearly instructed by Sage Jaimini that the results should be announced by consulting all the sources and taking the majority.

 Sage Jaimini writes

संवादात् प्रामाण्यं

saṁvādāt prāmāṇyaṁ

 

Hora Lagna Calculation according to Jataka Sara Sangraha:

 

Hora Lagna is very important lagna in Jaimini School. Sage Jaimini instructed to use this in Raja Yoga and Longevity purpose. For example, if a planet aspects Janma Lagna (Asc.), Hora Lagna (HL) and Ghatika Lagna (GL) becomes Yogada. Sage writes

 

जन्म काल घटिकास्वेक दृष्टासु राजानः

janma kāla ghaṭikāsveka dṛṣṭāsu rājānaḥ.

Janma = Natal Asc., Kala = Hora Lagna, Ghati = Ghatika Lagna.

Yet, there are two different variations of this Hora Lagna calculation in vogue. In Parasara method it known as Hora Lagna where as in Jaimini School it is known as Savayava Hora Lagna (SHL). I shall explain both below.

 

Hora Lagna in Parasara School:

In regular Parasara method, the time the birth time and the sun rise time is calculated and the Hora Lagna moves at a rate of a sign per one hour, where as the Janma Lagna (Ascendant) moves at a rate of one sign per two hours. So Hora lagna moves at twice the speed of Janma Lagna.

Here is the classic description of Hora Lagna.

Hora lagna is at the position of Sun at the time of sunrise. It moves at the rate of one rasi per hora (hour).  If sunrise takes place at 6:00 am and Sun is at 6s 4⁰47' then, Hora Lagna is at 6s 4⁰ 47' at 6:00 am, at 6s 19⁰ 47' at 6:30 am, at 7s 4⁰ 47' at 7:00 am, 8s 4⁰ 47' at 8:00 am and so on. Hora Lagna moves at the rate of 1/2⁰ per minute (i.e., 30⁰ per hour).

So, the Hora Lagna calculation in this Parasara School is based on the position of Sun at Sun rise and adding 1/2⁰ per minute to the position of Sun.

 

Savayava Hora Lagna in Jaimini School:

Jataka Sara Sangraha explains this and uses this Savayava Hora Lagna both in Raja Yoga and Longevity purposes. In this method, the Hora Lagna progresses from natal lagna itself rather than from Sun position based on Prakriti of natal lagna. The description is given below.

 

  1. Calculate the duration of day time (Diurnal) and night time (Nocturnal) separately.
  2. The diurnal is to be divided by 12 to get the duration of each Hora for day time.
  3. Similarly, the nocturnal duration is divided by 12 to get the duration of each Hora for night time.
  4. If the birth happens in day time, calculate the time elapsed from sun rise to the birth time. If the birth happened in night time, calculate the elapsed time from sun set to the birth time. This is called Ishta Kala.
  5. Divide the Ishta Kala by the duration of each Hora, note the quotient (Q) and remainder (R).
  6. The quotient (Q+1)th sign gives the Hora Lagna from Natal Lagna. If the Natal Lagna is odd, count (Q+1) signs zodiacally from Natal Lagna to get Savayava Hora Lagna. If the natal lagna is even, count (Q+1) signs anti-zodiacally from Natal Lagna to get Savayava Hora Lagna.
  7. The exact longitude of Savayava Hora Lagna can be gotten by proportionately. Please follow the example below.

Example :

The Sun Rise time                              =          05:47:44 Hrs.

The Sun set time                                =          18:51:47 Hrs

The Diurnal Duration                        =          13:04:03 Hrs

The Birth Time                                   =          15:30:00 Hrs

Birth Time – Sun Rise                        =          09:42:16 Hrs (Istha Kala) = 09.705 Hrs

Duration of each Hora                      =          13:04:03 / 12   =          01:05:21 Hrs. = 1.0889 Hrs

The No of Hora elapsed (Q)             =          Istha Kala / Duration of Each Hora

                                                            =          09:42:16 / 01:05:21

=          09.705 / 1.0889           =          8.92

                                                            =          8

The remainder (R)                             =          0.99316

Therefore the Savayava Hora Lagna will be the 9th sign from the natal lagna.

 

Now let us find out the longitude of the Savayava Hora Lagna in the sign.

 

Each sign is of 30⁰ and the time taken by Hora Lagna to traverse each sign is 01:05:21 Hrs.

Then, how many degrees does it traverse for 0.99316 Hrs

 

01:05:21 Hrs   -----      30⁰

0.99316 Hrs    -----      (30 * 0.99316) / 01.088 = 27.3442

                                    = 27⁰ 20' 39''   

If natal lagna is odd:

For example, if natal lagna is Libra, then the Savayava Hora Lagna will be at 27Ge20, which is 9th sign (Q+1) from Libra counting zodiacally.

 If natal lagna is even:

If the natal lagna is Scorpio, then the Savayava Hora Lagna will be at 27Pi20 which is 9th sign (Q+1) from Scorpio counting anti zodiacally.

 

Problems in this calculation of SHL:

 It is apparent that there is some confusion in this calculation, which is shown below.

 

  • Here, the starting point is Lagna sign, not the exact longitude of natal lagna in the sign, which is mathematically incorrect. Adding so many Horas to the exact longitude of the Ascendant is more technically correct. It makes a lot of difference, but the method given in this write up is easy to mentally calculate the Hora Lagna.
  • It is said that Hora Lagna be calculated anti zodiacally for an even sign. Then, what will be the exact longitude of the Hora Lagna in that sign? Whether shall it be calculated from the end of the sign?  The experts in this system explain that the longitude shall be calculated based on the remainder and from the staring of the sign only, not from the end of the sign. But, it looks not very convincing to me.
  • Here the diurnal and nocturnal durations are calculated and the rate of travel of Hora lagna is determined equally for each sign. But, in reality there are Deergha Ascending signs and a Hrasva Ascnding signs, that is each sign doesn’t take equal time to ascend. This reality is not taken care in this method.
  • Yet, it should be understood here that Jaimini School is different from Parasara. Parasara System focuses mostly on mathematical aspect, which is technically correct. In that School, we find the concepts like exact strength of the aspect like Pada Drishti , Artha Drishti based on the longitude of the planets.
  • In Jaimini a planet in a sign, whatever longitude it is placed in, aspects the other signs with full aspect.
  • IMHO, in Jaimini the exact longitude doesn’t play much important role. Most advanced planet in a sign, for example, 29th degree, becomes Atma Karaka which may be treated ineffective in Parasara System.
  • There were attempts like, Savayava Arudha, by taking exact degrees of the ascendant, which was not successful.

 

 

Application of this Savayava Hora Lagna:

This SHL shall invariably used in calculating the exact longitude of the native after determining the exact Longevity Kakshya.

 

Longevity must be ascertained from the following pairs

  1. Lagna Lord and 8th Lord (Use Vriddha Karika 8th house)
  2. Lagna and Moon. Some scholars use Moon and Saturn by interpreting Manda as Saturn, which was not used by any ancient commentary since the Katapayadi numeric gives Lagna. It shall be borne in mind that Saturn is not Ayush Karaka in Jaimini, he is Karaka for Kakshya Hrasa i.e; decreasing longevity compartment.
  3. Lagna and Savayava Hora Lagna (SHL)

 

If any two of the above pairs indicate same longevity, that will be final

If three pairs indicate three different, then longevity indicated by Lagna and Hora Lagna is final

If Moon is placed in either Lagna or 7th house, use that pair

There are many more factors to be considered like Kakshya Vrisshi and Kakshya Hrasa, which I will show later.

 

The following formulae may be effectively used to calculate the longevity of the native:

 

  • For a Full longevity:                  66 + (30 – D) * 1.1 Years
  • For a Medium longevity:                  33 + (30 – D) * 1.1 Years
  • For a Short longevity:                       12 + (30 – D) * 1.1 Years

 

The D in above formulae denotes the longitude of the decisive factor.

 

For example, if Savayava Hora Lagna and Lagna decides the longevity, then SHL at 27⁰ and Lagna at 20⁰, and the longevity compartment is medium

 

Longevity by SHL =             33 + (30 – 27) *1.1      = 36.3 Years

Longevity by Lagna =          33 + (30 – 20) *1.1      = 44 .0 Years

So, the total longevity will be (36.3 + 44.0) / 2.0      = 40.15 Years

Hence, the 5th Niryana Sula Dasa sign will be fatal for the native.

 

I end this blog by giving a classical reference from Deva Keralam which shows calculation of Hora Lagna below. I have shown this reference for some scholars arguing without referring the available literature and trying to prove their own theories and questioning the authenticity of ancient works.

 

Next blog, I will show you the commentary by Sri Venkatesa on Jaimini Sutras as how to calculate the Atma Karaka. Yes, you read correctly, Sri Venkatesa was one of the excellent commentators on Jaimini Sutras.  Learned Scholars may use this reference to understand the concept better.

दिवामानं रात्रिमानं ज्ञात्वा प्रत्येकं द्वादशधा विभज्य ओजयुग्मानुसारेण

जन्मलग्नस्योजक्रमेण युग्मे व्युत्क्रमेण इष्टजन्मकालघटिका यल्लग्नां भवति

divāmānaṁ rātrimānaṁ jñātvā pratyekaṁ dvādaśadhā vibhajya ojayugmānusāreṇa

janmalagnasyojakrameṇa yugme vyutkrameṇa iṣṭajanmakālaghaṭikā yallagnāṁ bhavati

 

I thank the friends who introduced the Jaimini concepts in Deva Keralam to me.

Regards,

Shanmukha 

Friday, June 19, 2009

Saptarishis Astrology Vol 6 Released

Om Namah Sivaya

Namaste All,

The Vol.6 of Saptarishis Astrology On-Line magazine was released on 18th June. In this issue, there are three of my articles are published. One very good feature in this issue, is Sapatarshis Gurukul, which contains the answers by eminent scholars for intriguing topics in Astrology. My articles are in the part 2 of the Volume 6. You can download this issue at www.saptarishisastrology.com website. Of course, you need to be a member, which is very easy and a few clicks away.

1. Jaimini Navamsa Part -2
2. Graha Chakra
3. Manipravala Rajayoga of Jaimini

In the part2 of Jaimini Navamsa article yogas in Karakamsa for Politics and professional fame are disussed. Graha Chakra article is an introduction to the Manipravala Rajayoga. IMHO, this is the first time Graha Chakra is explained in detail with examples, where as this lead was taken by our Guru Sri Rangacharya who first explained this Graha Chakra. This Graha Chakra is very important, since it is the base for the important Rajayoga Manipravala and Amatya Yogas, of course, to determine the Dasa Karakas for Rasi Dasas and for yogas form Yogada planet.

Dasa Karakas are the linchpin for the prediction of any Rasi Dasas which has been forgotten by the contemporary internet knowledge on Jaimini. This Dasa Karaka system was extensively used by all the ancient commentators like Krishna Mishra, his son Somanatha, Raghava Bhatta etc.

In modern times, it was extensively used by Sri Vemuri Ramamurthis Sastri, the legend of Jaimini system in the last century. He never writes dasa predictions without Dasa Karakas.Though he used a no. of Jaimini Rasi Dasas depending on the horoscopic conditions, yet his favourite being the "Pada Nathamsa Dasa". As you may know this dasa was exposed by Krishna Mishra in "Jyotish Phalaratnamala", starts from sign occupied by the lord of Arudha Lagna in Navamsa Chart and proceeds in Navamsa chart only. As Arudha and Navamsa are connected with this Dasa, this is a Phalita Dasa as well as a Ayurdasa.

Regards,
Shanmukha

Monday, May 25, 2009

An Introduction To Jataka Sara Sangarha

Om Namah Sivaya


Namaste All,

I have promised to introduce the classical works on Jaimini Astrology on this personal blog and of course it is theme of the blog. I am fortunate to study this text, of course not extensively. People can appreciate the genius of the work by reading “Jaimini Sutramritam”, by Sri Rangacharya, who has done an excellent research on this work. Keeping to my promise, I am writing a small introduction below, on “Jataka Sara Sangraha” by Raghava Bhatta.

“Jataka Sara Sangahra”, an important classical work on Jaimini, was written by Gottimukkula Raghava Bhatta, s/o Ramachandra Diskshita. . It is believed that he lived in around 1650 AD since the example horoscope given by him was worked out by the scribe gives the year as 1604 AD. It was told by the Guru of the scribe, Sri Iranganti Rangacharya, that Raghava Bhatta is a Telugu speaking scholar, and might have hailed from Telangana area of Andhra Pradesh State. The above work was written in Sanskrit language and this scribe is fortunate to have a look at text in a manuscript from though, written in Telugu script. It was printed with Telugu script an hundred years ago, and since then nobody tried to bring it to astrological fraternity.

Most of us are in a view that the delineation of Rasi Dasas is not indicated in the classical works. This text obviates the above notion and gives many clues about interpreting them. It goes to the extent of giving the results specific and unique to each Rasi Dasa.

For example, it indicates, by the authority of a Vriddha Karika, that the results of Drik Dasa shall be studied from

Dasa Sign
Dasa Sign in Navamsa
Dasa Sign in Dwadasamsa. (This is very special and specific to this Dasa)
Sign Arudha of Dasa Sign

Raghava Bhatta indicates that aspect of the planets on the Dasa sign and their respective Aspect Arudhas play an important role in Drik Dasa. Probably this is the reason for this Dasa be called as Drik Dasa. This again obviates the calculation of Drik Dasa based on aspect of signs as is currently being done by most of the scholars.

The example horoscope given by him in this work is given below, generated using JHora Software and of course the degrees of the planets do change a bit. Since, we never know the Ayanamsa used then, this is quite understandable. It was mentioned that Sakabdah 1526 Krodhi Samvatsara Jyeshta Suddha Shashti Guruvaram 50 Ghadiya 45 Vighadiya, Lagna Meena 23⁰ 46′ 41″.

This comes to June 03, 1604, TOB: 1:58 Hrs (Early morning)

Date: June 3, 1604
Time: 1:58:00
Time Zone: 5:30:00 (East of GMT)
Place: 78 E 30' 00", 17 N 27' 00"
Altitude: 0.00 meters

Lunar Yr-Mo: Krodhi - Jyeshtha
Tithi: Sukla Shashthi (Ve) (94.28% left)
Vedic Weekday: Saturday (Sa)
Nakshatra: Aasresha (Me) (39.95% left)
Yoga: Vyaghata (Ve) (35.04% left)
Karana: Kaulava (Ma) (88.56% left)

Sunrise: 5:43:37 (June 2)
Sunset: 18:42:46 (June 2)
Janma Ghatis: 50.5994

Ayanamsa: 18-20-10.57
Sidereal Time: 18:28:07

Body Longitude Nakshatra Pada Rasi Navamsa

Lagna 20 Pi 31' 25.85" Reva 2 Pi Cp
Sun - AmK 23 Ta 59' 14.12" Mrig 1 Ta Le
Moon - AK 24 Cn 40' 24.78" Asre 3 Cn Aq
Mars - MK 21 Vi 47' 44.68" Hast 4 Vi Cn
Mercury - GK 1 Ge 57' 12.00" Mrig 3 Ge Li
Jupiter (R) - DK 1 Sg 38' 47.20" Mool 1 Sg Ar
Venus - PK 3 Cn 51' 12.67" Push 1 Cn Le
Saturn (R) - BK 23 Sc 14' 12.74" Jye 2 Sc Cp
Rahu 17 Li 38' 27.14" Swat 4 Li Pi
Ketu 17 Ar 38' 27.14" Bhar 2 Ar Vi
Maandi 5 Aq 20' 59.02" Dhan 4 Aq Sc
Gulika 23 Cp 38' 18.49" Dhan 1 Cp Le



According to Graha Sputa given by the author Moon changes to Leo 4⁰ 9′ 5″, of course there is some variance at the longitudes of other planets as well. The software gives a day as Saturday, where as it was mentioned to be Thursday by the author. Nevertheless it gives correct year as 1604 AD which is actual difference from Saka Samvatsara to the modern calendar of 78 years

Sri Raghava Bhatta divided his work broadly into two categories one Ayurdaya (Longevity) and other Phalita (Predictive part). The first part deals with the calculation of longevity and various AyurDasas. Next he dealt various phalita Dasas for normal and raja yoga natives. And then lastly, he dealt with the Raja Yogas from Jaimini Angle. He always makes a point in quoting the relevant Vriddha Karika verse supporting this interpretation. This is very important for us for the very reason this system has been a secret and nowadays new theories are cropping up without any solid reference.

He gave the following very special lagans that you never find elsewhere.

(Correction: It was informed by s/shri Sun22 and Ast that these following Lagnas were mentioned in Deva Keralam. Thanks to them for the information.)

Savayava Hora Lagna (Extensively used in Ayurdaya)
Sapada Ghatika Lagna (Chaturthamsa Lagna) ( --do-- )
Ayur Lagna ( --do-- )

Owing to the nature of this blog, though complete exposition of the parameters can’t be given, but various important Dasas mentioned in the work are given below for the benefit of the readers.

AyurDasas – Longevity based Dasas.

Darpana Dasa
Niryana Sula Dasa (For Self, Fahter, Mother Etc.)
Jaya Bhava Pamsa Dasa
Atmano Bhava Pamsa Dasa
Hora Dasa
Atmanadi Dasa
Brahma Maheswara Dasa
Sthira Dasa (Start from Brahma Graha)
Varnada Dasa
Drekkana Dasa (Both Ayur Dasa and Phalita Dasa)

It must be understood that though the above list is long, yet there are very specific and distinct rules of interpretation of each Dasa. For example the “Maraka Grahas” in Darpana Dasa are different from Niryana Sura Dasa, again different from Jaya Bhava Pamsa Dasa etc.

Phalaita Dasas (Predictive Dasas)

Raghava Bhatta has given a number of Phalita Dasas and some of them are secret as well. The following are for the benefit of readers.

Some of the Sampat Dasas :

1. Chara Dasa (Male and Female) for all horoscopes
2. Chara Paryaya Dasa
3. Sthira Paryaya Dasa
4. Trikona Dasa (Gochara Dasa)
5. Drik Dasa
6. Manduka Dasa
7. Nakshatra Dasa (Tara Lagna Dasa)
8. Bhava Rahasya Dasa
9. Rasya Bheda Brahma Dasa
10. Karaka Dasa (Atma Karaka Kendradi Dasa)
11. Upagraha Karaka Dasa
12. Lagna Kendradi Dasa
13. Brahma Dasa
14. Sthira Dasa (Phalita Dasa)
15. Yogartha Dasa
16. Drekkana Dasa (Phalita Dasa)
17. Prakarantara Drekkana Dasa
18. Atmasa Bhavapamsa Dasa (Calculated in Navamsa Chart)

As usual, he indicated the rules specific and distinct to each and every Dasa in addition to the general rules to be applied in all Phalita Rasi Dasas.



Raghava Bhatta gave a very peculiar way of reckoning the Chara Dasa. His interpretation of Chara Dasa is based on Padakrama of Chara, Sthira and Ubhaya rasis. Again, the dasa years calculation is also different to all other and he gives a wonderful explanation of his interpretation. Scholars adpet in Vedantic literature, for that matter, six parts of Vedangas do appreciate his interpretation.




He indicates the Chara Paryaya, Sthira Paryaya, Trikona and Drik Dasas are Sampat dasas and be used in Rajayoga Horoscopes and the results of those four dasas are equal. Trikona dasa needs a mention here. Most of us don’t know why this is also called Gochara Dasa. This excellent work explains the Gochara in Jaimini way and its application in especially in Trikona Dasa. That’s the precise reason why it is called Gochara Dasa. If we understand the Trikona Dasa as exposed in this work, we understand what Gochara meant in Jaimini. We can learn the Paka and Bhoga Signs distinct to each and every Sampat dasa, and of course most important and least mentioned by contemporary Internet knowledge, Dasa Karakas.

Next, He moves on to the Raja Yogas in Jaimini way, quoting the authority of various Vriddha Karika Verses supporting his interpretation of Upadesa Sutras of Jaimini.

Most of the above mentioned dasas can be learnt from my Guru Sri Iranganti Rangacharya’s commentary “Jaimini Sutramritam”.

The above list may not be very comprehensive, but this scribe tried his best to bring forth the various topics discussed in the work. This scribe feels fortunate and privileged to study the manuscript of this wonderful work. He tried his best to procure the manuscripts and fortunately he could get some of them, which has been put for download at the http://www.saptarishisastrology.com/ website. Of course, since the text is in Telugu script, people who could decipher the ancient writing of Telugu and understand Sanskrit could benefit from the manuscript.





Warm Regards,



Shanmukha

Friday, March 6, 2009

Naisargika Strength of Signs - An Appraisal

Om Namah Sivaya

Namaste friends,

Yes, it’s been a long time since I posted a blog. Meantime, I have been busy with studying some of the wonderful commentaries on this Jaimini system. And, I was also busy with proof reading and other works for a book by my guru Sri Rangacharya. It is a manual on Jaimini Astrology in Telugu language. We hope to release it early March this year.

With all your blessings and best wishes, I wrote my first article named “Jaimini Navamsa – Karakamsa” which is going to be published in the annual issue of Saptarishi’s Astrology magazine. As you all know, that magazine is a free online magazine. I have discussed Ishta Devata and devotion for various sects of Hinduism with some examples. Please download it form http://www.saptarishisastrology.com/ and offer your feedback. I must thank the visitors of this blog for their encouragement.

Now, I am writing a very brief article below. I promise to give some more details of Drig dasa in coming days, since whatever the info available in print or on net about this wonderful dasa system is incomplete. There has been wonderful exposition of this dasa system by both Raghava Bhatta and Nrisimha Suri in their respective commentaries.

Here goes the topic of this blog.


Naisargika Strength of Signs – An Appraisal

Jaimini Maharshi dealt with four sources of strength of Rasi. Most scholars mixed up these sources of strength. But, if we study the Sanskrit commentaries, it would be evident that they are very clear as to which strength to be used in a particular situation.

Though I am not going to write all types of strengths here, for I promised to write it for a magazine. I just want to mention here, though very brief, two very important issues to trigger interest in the minds of readers.

Sage Jaimini instructed the Naisargika strength of signs in the following order.

Dual Sign > Fixed Sign > Movable sign.

So, the Dual sign has the most natural strength. Did we ever try to understand the practical application of this strength except using it to determine the stronger between two signs?

As I already mentioned elsewhere, Argala shall be calculated only for an aspecting planet, neither for a sign nor Lagna. Sage Jaimini and other ancient commentaries were very clear on this issue. But, most scholars ignore this very important rider and explain everything under the sky with Argala. That approach perhaps given by Sri V. Suryanarayana Murthy in his Jataka Narayaneeyam, which, I believe Sri Sanjay followed, doesn’t fetch any thing further in this system. Of course, as you all know I ignore whatever given in BPHS regarding Jaimini pointers.

Krishna Mishra in his Phalaratnamala, his son Somanatha Mishra in his Kalpalatha, extensively used the combination of these two (Argala and Naisargika Strength) to assess the Rajayoga of the native, which is explained very briefly below.

The following points must be remembered in assessing the Rajayoga.

If an aspecting planet placed in Movable sign, Poornargala (4/4) is formed if unobstructed Argala formed in three Mukhya Argala signs. This Poornargala will confer Rajayoga.

If an aspecting planet placed in Fixed sign, Tripadargala (3/4) is formed if unobstructed Argala formed at least in two Mukhya Argala signs. This Tripadargala will confer Rajayoga.

If an aspecting planet placed in Dual sign, Ardhargala (2/4) is formed if unobstructed Argala formed in at least one Mukhya Argala sign. This Ardhargala will confer Rajayoga.

For any aspecting planet placed in any type of sign, one more Padaargla (1/4) is formed, if unobstructed benefic Argala (Subha Graha Argala) formed in Gouna Argala Sign (either in 5th or 9th).

As you can see in the above three points that Ardhargala formed for an aspecting planet in Dual sign can confer Rajayoga, where as for a planet in Movable sign needs Poornargala to give Rajayoga. And, planet placed in Dual sign only can aspect other Dual signs.

Please note I used the phrase Subha Graha Argala only for 4th point, not for earlier three points. It must be again borne in mind that any planet, either natural benefic or natural malefic, confers Subha Argala in Mukhya Argala signs.

That’s why Sage Jaimini instructed us that Dual sign is the strongest sign. Do you understand why I always stress the importance of studying the Sanskrit commentaries to understand this science?

Well, I know the above discussion is neither complete nor very comprehensive in itself. Some may question the use of all this, if the above points are not substantiated by practical illustrations. My answer, for now, is to kindly read the book “A Manual of Jaimini Astrology”, by Sri Rangacharya to learn the practical examples.

In fact, I wrote this blog a couple of days back, but could not post it till today. As a bonus I wanted to add this following point.

There is a very peculiar yoga in this Jaimini system, which grants wonderful Raja Yoga for the native. It is connected to the aspect of debilitated planets. For example,

1. If a debilitated planet in 6rd or 8th house aspecting Janma Lagna
2. If a debilitated 6rd or 8th lord aspecting Janma Lagna

Well, there are much more to mention. Sri Rangacharya has made extensive study of these Yogas and vouches the practical application. He calculated the applicability of these special yogas for each lagna and found that Taurus gets much % of applicability.

It was mentioned by Sri Vadrevu Suryanarayana Murthy in his Jataka Narayaneeyam, that he found a special sutra in the Jaimini manuscript available with him. Of course, that Sutra is not found in any other Jaimini Sutras Book. It reads as follows

Na Vrishabha Chetyeke.

It can be argued that the word vrishabha in the above sutra refers to sign Taurus or its numeric value of above sutra. Yet, Sri Murthy interprets that Taurus sign is the best of all Lagnas.

Is it the upadess of Sage Jaimini to treat Taurus lagna as a special Lagna, which gets a different Raja Yoga by debilitated aspecting planet.



You can send your feedback at Shanmukha.t@gmail.com.
Seeking your blessings,

Shanmukha

Friday, December 19, 2008

What Went Wrong With BPHS - 2



What Went Wrong With BPHS - 2


Om Namah Sivaya

Dear Friends,

First things first. How are you doing? Do you know that Saptarishis Astrology Vol4 was released yesterday, on December 18th 2008, to be precise? Please visit http://www.saptarishisastrology.com/ and download the Global Free Magazine for a good treat.

In the previous post in this blog, I have given one verse from BPHS and the counterpart from Vriddha Karika. Now, I am going to bring another Gem below, which again shows my point. Yet, I want to go on record, that I have no disrespect fro Sage Parasara. I worship him as a great Sage who gas graced this wonderful science to the mankind. Similarly, I have the same respect for Sage Jaimini, who propounded another wonderful system, which gives rare combinations. My point here is that to understand Jaimini, we need to consult Vriddaha Karikas and ancient commentaries. Though we need not put BPHS aside, but merely accepting whatever there in now available BPHS as authenticated is not good. Treating Jaimini as contemporary to Sage Parasara is respecting both Sages that they deserve. I urge the knowledgeable Astrological fraternity to study Vriddha Karikas, since a lot of knowledge has been corrupted and much need to be brought into light.

Now, I am giving another sloka dealing Karakamsa. The relevant verse of BPHS quoted by Sri Sanjay Rath in his commentary on Jaimini Sutras.









Well, since the sloka is very clear, no translation is given here. Now, see the relevant Vriddha Karika sloka.


Do you see the similarity and the differences? This verse gives much more than what BPHS gives. It attributes the results
1. Karakamsa
2. Lagnamsa
3. Karaka Rasi
4. Upagraha and other grahas

By any means, Vriddha Karika verse is more exhaustive and deals many concepts in one verse. Most of the Jaimini literature now on Internet deals about Karakamsa in Navamsa chart, but this verse asks us to consider Atma Karaka in Rasi chart as well.

Some may get a doubt “What this Upagraha is?” There lies the key with Jataka Sara Sangraha by Raghava Bhatta again. It not only deals the concept of Upagraha in Jaimini system, but also a dasa of that planet. Now, do you understand why I say our understanding on Jaimini now is only tip of iceberg?

I am not saying everything in ancient commentaries is fool proof. But, do we know that these concepts exist at all in the first place? How long shall we be in darkness regarding Jaimini system? Come on friends, let us start unlearn something and learn Jaimini from start. I request all to give a serious try to these ancient commentaries. I can tell you that much work is in progress in the background to bring these commentaries to light. Let us wish all the best to those volunteers doing such noble work. As per the information available with me, I can tell you that we are going to see them very soon. But, we shall have to submit the translation or the commentary in English in return to the benefit of the fraternity.

Are you ready to take on?

Warm regards,
Shanmukha.

Wednesday, December 10, 2008

Krishna Mishra Navamsa – Karakamsa


Om Namah Sivaya

In Jaimini System, Sage Jaimini gave utmost importance to Karakamsa Lagna. He has dealt with very specific and rare combinations from Karakamsa Lagna. Most scholars advocated Parasara Navamsa to analyze Karakamsa. But, Krishna Mishra in his Jyotish Phalaratnamala[1] advocated another way of reckoning Navamsa in line with Prakriti[2] chakra reckoning. Yet, most scholars like Sri Sanjay Rath reject this Navamsa reckoning, and my Guru advocates using this also along with Parasara Navamsa.

The relavent sloka by Krishna Mishra is given here for the benefit of readers.











The translation[3] : For Aries, Leo and Sagittarius the Navamsa reckoning starts direct from Aries. For Taurus, Virgo and Capricorn, the Navamsa count is reverse from Capricorn. For Gemini, Libra and Aquarius, the Navamsa count is direct from Libra. For Cancer, Scorpio and Pisces, the count is reverse from Cancer. It must be understood that Navamsa reckoning always starts from Movable sign, which is in accordance with Parasara with an exception of Prakriti Chakra.

The following table can be used as ready reckoner with advantage.








Now, I am going to explain the application of Karakamsa to know the Ishta Devata for the native. It must be understood that whatever the combinations from Karakamsa must read from only the Navamsa chart constructed in the above explained manner. Karakamsa is the sign in which Atmakaraka planet placed in and Istha Devata for the native must be seen from 12th house of Karakamsa. If 12th is not occupied by any planet then the planet aspecting it, then lord of that sign is considered.

I am giving the relevant adhikara sutras from Jaimini for ready reference.












Example Chart 1: Sri Ramakrishna Paramahamsa, 18-2-1836; 6:23AM, 87E44, 22N53, Raman Ayanamsa.














Note: Readers may criticize me for using a different horoscope than the usual one, but I have seen a hand calculated horoscope by an eminent scholar Sri Vedavyas, PhD, where he uses probably Raman Ayanamsa. In that horoscope Moon gets more longitude than Mars, where as our software gives the other way.

Sri Ekkirala Vedavyas PhD was an IAS Officer with traditional learning n Vedic sciences, he authored many books on Hinduism, Vedic Sciences and Established an University of Vedic Sciences. He did his doctoral studies in Dating of Mahabharata War.


The data given by Sri Vedavyas is given below for your ready reference.


18th Feb 1836, 6:23 hrs 22N53, 87E 44, Ayanamsa 20Deg6 min

Asc : 304D53', Sun: 308D19', Moon: 223D15', Mars:293D9', Merc: 316D33' , Jup: 76D0' ,

Ven: 339D29', Sat: 195D10', Rahu: 34D20', Ketu: 214D21'

In the horoscope of Sri Ramakrishna Paramahamsa, two planets occupy equal degrees, though minutes are different. According to Vriddha Karika, when two planets occupy same degree, then only Rahu can be considered for Chara Karaka scheme. Yet here, since the tie is between AK and AmK, and Rahu is prohibited for being Atmakaraka, we have to decide the AK using Naisargika[4] Strength of the planets. In this system, Moon is considered stronger than Mars, so Moon becomes AK here.

But since Moon is conjunct with Sun with no digital (paksha) strength, Mars can be taken as Atmakaraka, and Moon settling for Amatya karaka. Here I stick to the tradition.

Now, look at Parasara Navamsa, Moon occupies Aries Navamsa and 12th from Karakamsa is not occupied by any planet. Sun from Sagittarius and Venus from Virgo aspects the 12th house Pisces. Jaimini instructs us that Bhakti towards Shiva and Lakshmi for Sun and Venus respectively. But, it is well known fact that Sri Paramahamsa was strong devotee of Goddess Kali.

Now, loot at the Krishna Mishra Navamsa given above. AK Moon occupies Aries Navamsa in this chart with no planet in 12th house from Karakamsa and aspects by Rahu and Sun from Sagittarius, Ketu from Gemini.

Observe the two adhikara sutras regarding Sun, Ketu and Rahu above.

Though Rahu is not in 12th house from Karakamsa lagna, but the he strongly aspects Pisces from the frontal aspect of Sagittarius. The planets Sun, Rahu and Ketu clearly indicate the devotion towards Saivite Gods and especially the eternal attachment that Sri Ramakrishna had towards Goddess Durga.

Amatyakaraka is Mars and Sage Jaimini instructs us to see devata bhakti also from 6th planet from Amatyakaraka vide Sutra Amatya Dase Chaivam. Hence the 6th planet from AmK Mars is Rahu. Count like this, Mars, Mercury, Jupiter, Venus, Saturn, Rahu. So, Rahu indicate bhakti towards Goddess Kali, Tamasic form of Goddess Duga.

Example Chat 2: Srila Bhakti Rakshaka Sridhara Maharaja; October 12th, 1895; 23:38 Hrs LMT, (-5.53.20), Mayapur, 88E11, 22N34, India. (Source: Robert Coch’s The Spirtual Dimensions in Vedic Astrology)











Atmakaraka is Sun placed in Virgo in Rasi Chart, in Virgo in Parasara Navamsa and in Taurus in Krishna Mishra Navamsa chart. If you look at Parasara Navamsa, Mars occupies 12th house from Karakamsa which shows devotion towards Nrisimha Deva for a Vaishanavite. But Srila Sridhara Maharaja was ardent devotee of Lord Krishna.

Now, look at Krishna Mishara Navamsa chart given above. AK Sun occupies Taurus Navamsa and 12th house is occupied by Moon. Doesn’t it clearly show devotion towards Lord Krishna for a vaishanavite. Look a the 2nd house from Karakamsa, occupied by Mars and aspected by Jupiter, Mercury and Rahu from Pisces and Ketu from Virgo. The influence of two benefic planets Jupiter and Mercury indicates that Srila Sridhara Maharaja’s excellence in Vedic scriptures, his authorship and renunciation in life. You can’t find these yogas from Parasara Navamsa chart.

Example 3: A Male native, birth details not disclosed for obvious reasons
















This is my chart and over the years I have been puzzled about my Ishta Devata. I *feel* I am strongly attached towards Lord Rama and Lord Shiva, yet the Parasara Navamsa doesn’t give any clue about that. If you look at Krishna Mishra Navamsa chart, Atmakaraka Venus occupies Sagittarius Navamsa and its 12th is occupied by Sun aspected by Ketu, Mercury and Mars from Aries. It explains the native’s attachement towards Lord Rama.

I know these three examples, may not be sufficient to prove the efficacy of Krishna Mishra Navamsa chart, yet it may instigate the enthusiasm in the students of Astrology about the ancient commentators’ knowledge. That’s the precise reason why I have been repeatedly requesting on the forums to study the ancient works, though my comments seem to be harsh at times. This Navamsa chart must be used in practical charts; in fact my Guru simply calls it Jaimini Navamsa chart.

Hence, I request all to read ancient commentaries Vriddha karikas not the BPHS. God willing, I will bring these gems in this blog.

Let the knowledge come from everywhere

Warm regards,
Shanmukha

[1] Jyotish Phalaratnamala is very important classic to understand Jaimini. No scholar yet fully uncovered the concepts it introduced, in my humble view.
[2] This Prakriti chakra reckoning was explained in my earlier posts. Please have a look.
[3] Adopted from Jaimini Sutramritam by Sri Iranganti Rangacharya.
[4] Refer to Sutrartha Prakasika. Though I don’t have complete verse right now, but it reads like “Manda Avanisunu Shashanketyaadi ….”. It means Moon is stronger than Mars.


Friday, December 5, 2008

What Went Wrong with BPHS
Om Namah Sivaya

Namaste All,

Members on Sohamsa group definitely get furious by the comments passed on by me regarding BPHS and Sri Narasimha’s interpretation of Drig dasa. In fact, most of the list members may be in the view that whatever Sage Jaimini told in his upadesa sutras are also told by Sage Parasara in BPHS. And Sri Sanjay and others also advocated the same point. My Guru Sri Iranganti Rangacharya always tells that to learn Jaimini one must study the Vriddha Karikas. I just reiterated the same on the list. I also pointed out the slokas given by Sri Narasimha are just in toto Vriddha Karika slokas. In fact, I went to the extent of quoting that without Vriddhas, is like Sailing without a compass.

Now in this post, I am going to prove my point once again with the following example.
The Adhikara Sutra of Jaimini regarding Trikona Dasa.



On page 214 of Jaimini Maharishi’s Upadesa Sutras, Sri Sanjay gave the relevant sloka from BPHS regarding the interpretation of Trikona Dasa.






The commentary by Sanjay reads as follows.
The Trikona dasas begin from the ascendant, fifth or ninth house whichever is strongest. The periods of the dasas are the same as Chara dasa. After the trines, the dasa progress to the second house from the initiating sign and its trines and so on. The succeeding signs are reckoned zodiacally or reverse depending on whether the ascendant in odd or even.

Now, I am giving below the relevant Vriddha Karika slokas and readers can easily find out what went wrong.
Let me explain, why I quote only Sanjay’s translation here. Sanjay clearly knows what Chara paryaya dasa is and he explained the same in page 298 and 299 of his book, though he doesn’t follow all types of padakrama. When the second line of the sloka in BPHS clearly says

Charaparaayavaddasha à Chara Paryaya + vat + dasha à Like Chara Paryaya dasa.

So, BPHS sloka asks us to start this dasa like chara paryaya dasa, but Sri Sanjay interprets that dasa is same as Chara dasa. Refer to his translation quoted above. Do you see the difference? The dasa should be like Chara paryaya dasa, not Chara dasa.

Don’t you see that some lines in between are missing in the slokas of BPHS? The missing lines are the ones that differentiate this particular dasa from other sampat dasa namely Chara Paryaya dasa. Does any body know that we have conditional dasas in Jaimini as well? In my humble view, this one is a conditional dasa. The key of this dasa is the stronger house. Then, how to select the stronger house between Lagna, 5th house and 9th house? Does anyone here offer any idea of what Jaimini instructed regarding this dasa? The answer lies with Jataka Sara Sangraha by Raghava Bhatta, which I will bring soon.

Next, the Vriddha Karika sloka deals with how to choose the starting dasa sign for male and female natives. The key here is one source of strength. Some scholars mix up the strengths without understanding the purpose of each source of strength.

Meanwhile readers will do well to read my Guru’s translation of Jaimini Sutras, where it was clearly explained. In fact, this blog is named in reverence to my Guru’s book Jaimini Sutramritam.

Let the knowledge come from everywhere

Warm Regards,
Shanmukha.

Hit Counter after May 4 2015

website hit counter